UGC agency vs marketplace vs DIY comes down to who does the work. With DIY outreach you find, brief and pay creators yourself: the cheapest in cash and the most expensive in time. A marketplace brings creators to you and handles payment, and you still pick and approve each one. Freelance sites suit a few one-off videos. An agency runs the whole thing for a fee, which makes sense once your time is worth more than the fee. For most small app teams, a marketplace or DIY is the right place to start.
This guide compares the four routes on published costs, time to the first video and how much control you keep, using the platforms' own pages and two app founders' first-hand accounts.
The four routes at a glance
| Route | What you pay | Time to first video | Who picks creators | Who handles contracts and payment | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DIY outreach | Creator fees only; no platform fee | Depends on replies; can take months to find creators who work | You | You | Founders with time, and apps still finding the right format |
| Freelance site (Upwork, Fiverr) | Creator fees plus a client fee per payment | Agreed with each freelancer | You | The site holds payment; you write the scope | A handful of one-off videos for your own channels |
| Creator marketplace | Creator fees plus a platform fee, a subscription, or both | Insense says as little as 7 days from brief launch for apps | You, from creators who apply | The platform | Small teams that want several creators without managing payments |
| UGC or influencer agency | Creator fees plus an agency fee or monthly retainer, often with minimums | Set in your agreement | The agency, with your sign-off | The agency | Teams with budget and no time to run a creator program |

What does each route cost? The published fees
| Route | Example | Published fee |
|---|---|---|
| DIY outreach | TikTok One creator marketing | Creators are paid directly; no minimum ad spend |
| Freelance site | Upwork | A 5% service fee on the Basic plan, plus a contract initiation fee. Upwork's help centre puts the Basic fee at up to 7.99%. |
| Freelance site | Fiverr | A service fee of 5.5% on all orders, plus $3.00 for orders under $100 |
| Marketplace | Myah | No subscription; Myah's fee is 10% on top of what you pay creators |
| Marketplace | JoinBrands | Free plan with a 15% platform fee; paid plans from $99 a month |
| Agency | FNLY | 20% on creator fees, at least $500 per campaign; campaigns from $2,500 total budget; 20 to 50% more for ad usage rights |
| Managed service | Billo Managed Service | From $2,000 a month, plus video costs |
| Managed service | SideShift Managed | Starting campaign budget of $20,000 a month |
Agency and managed-service prices are the ones to read most carefully. Ask whether creator fees are passed through at cost or marked up, what the minimums are, and who holds the usage rights at the end.
What do 10 videos cost each way?
The worked example below uses one made-up assumption for every route: ten creators, each paid $150 for one video. It shows how the fees add up, not what creators charge.
| Route | How it adds up | Cash cost |
|---|---|---|
| DIY outreach | $1,500 creator fees, paid directly | $1,500, plus your time |
| Upwork, Basic | $1,500 + 5% service fee, plus contract initiation fees | $1,575 and up |
| Fiverr | 10 orders × ($150 + 5.5%) | $1,582.50 |
| Myah | $1,500 + 10% fee | $1,650 |
| Agency (FNLY's published model) | $1,500 + 20% fee, raised to the $500 minimum; below the $2,500 minimum campaign budget | $2,500 minimum |

On cash alone, the routes are close until you reach an agency, where minimums dominate a small batch. The bigger difference is time, which the table leaves out.
Is DIY outreach really cheaper?
In cash, yes. In time, the two best-documented app stories say it is a full-time job.
Praktika's co-founder and CEO Adam Turaev told the Sub Club podcast, as reported by RevenueCat: "I had spent probably like ten months doing this. It was a full time job." He described sending emails and messages to influencers, of whom "just a few of them just worked out." One of those videos, by his account, did about 10 million views each on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube, in the month Praktika went from about $1M to $12M in annual recurring revenue. Those figures are the founder's own, not independently verified.
Cal AI's co-founder Jake Castillo described the same grind on the Sub Club podcast: "you are sending thousands and thousands of messages to creators all the time, and most of them aren't responding." And: "We did that for 18 months every single day." As the program grew, he said he "built systems and automations out over time" to manage hundreds of creators.
Many teams still choose to run creators themselves. In Influencer Marketing Hub's 2026 benchmark survey, 66.3% of those answering said they run their programs entirely in-house. What DIY costs you is the hours, not the fees.
Which route fits your app?
- You have more time than budget, and you are still learning what works. Start with DIY outreach. You learn the formats and creators first-hand, and you pay no platform fee.
- You want several creators posting, without managing payments yourself. Use a creator marketplace. Creators apply to your brief, you pick and approve, and the platform handles payment. See our comparison of UGC platforms and our guide to TikTok One for options.
- You need a few videos for your own ads or app store page. A freelance site works if you write a tight scope and spell out the usage rights.
- You have budget and no one to run the program. Use an agency or managed service, and check its minimums against how many videos you need.

The routes also combine. A common path is to start with DIY or a marketplace to find the formats that work, then add help once the volume makes managing creators a job in itself. Praktika keeps paid ads and its organic creator program apart: "This is paid ads and organic content. This creator program that those two are separate streams. We don't mix them up," Adam Turaev said.
What to check before you commit to any route
- Who signs with the creator, and who pays them.
- Usage rights: organic posts only, or ads too, for how long and where. Our guide to UGC usage rights for paid ads lists the questions.
- The fee base: a percentage of creator fees, a flat retainer or a subscription, and any minimums.
- Whether creator fees are marked up, if someone else pays the creators for you.
- Who posts: the creator on their own account, or files delivered to you.
- Approval and revisions: how many, and who decides.
- Disclosure: paid posts must be labelled. The FTC says creators should disclose any financial relationship with a brand.
For the full hiring process on any route, see how to hire UGC creators.
Where Myah fits
Myah is a marketplace, not an agency: the app picks the creators and approves every video. An app posts a campaign with a brief and the pay, creators apply with their portfolio, and the creator posts each approved video on their own TikTok or Instagram. Myah tracks the views on each post. There is no subscription; Myah's fee is 10% on top of what you pay creators.
If you want someone else to source, brief and manage creators for you, an agency or managed service is the better fit.
Common questions
Is a creator agency worth it for a small app?
Usually not for a first batch. Published agency minimums can exceed what a small test needs. An agency makes more sense once you know which formats work and want someone to run the volume.
What is the difference between a creator agency and a creator marketplace?
An agency chooses and manages creators for you for a fee. A marketplace brings creators to you and handles payment, while you choose and approve them.
How long does it take to get the first creator video?
On marketplaces, Insense says as little as 7 days from brief launch for apps, and JoinBrands gives creators 10 days once they are approved and have the product. DIY outreach depends on how fast creators reply, and founders describe it taking months to find creators who work.
Can I use Upwork or Fiverr for TikTok creator videos?
Yes, for videos you post or run yourself. Write the deliverables, posting and usage rights into the order, because a freelance site does not set them for you.
Should an app founder do creator outreach themselves?
Early on, it is a good way to learn what works. Both Praktika and Cal AI did it themselves. Plan for it to take real time, and move to a marketplace or help when it starts to crowd out the rest of the work.
Choose the work you want to own
Every route gets you creator videos. The difference is who finds the creators, who pays them and who checks the work. Pick the one that matches the time you have.
Myah is a UGC marketplace where apps get creators posting about them. Post one campaign, approve every video, and pay per video or at view targets.



